please do NOT place an order via any comment sections on Facebook posts-as this can get lost along the way.
if you have any questions, please email me: prairiehousebaker@gmail.com or message me on facebook.
prairie bake house offerings
at prairie bake house, our menu is a collection of "treasured notes" from the kitchens of our past. Aren't recipes just a handwritten note from the threads of our culinary heritage?
we hope to offer you bakes that don't just satisfy a craving, but act as a "story" to take us back to the feelings of home and family gatherings.
our 2026 menu focuses on "simple indulgence"—reminding us of simplier days and time spent preparing special things for family or friends. whether it's a lemon loaf, cinnamon roll or a spoon of hot fudge sauce over ice cream, each bite is a nod designed to connect you back to those memories shared around the family table.
prairie bake house cutie cakes
4 inch and 6 inch layer cakes ~ perfect for couples or a small celebration
vintage vanilla bean
vintage vanilla bean with vanilla buttercream.
4 inch cutie cake
15.00
6 inch layer cake
25.00
lush lemon
lush lemon cake with lemon buttercream
4 inch cutie cake
15.00
6 inch layer cake
25.00
birthday party confetti cake
birthday party confetti layer cake w/ confetti vanilla frosting
4 inch cutie cake
15.00
6 inch layer cake
25.00
intense chocolate layer cake with choice of frosting
rich dark chocolate cake with choice of frosting: vanilla bean or fudgy chocolate buttercream
4 inch cutie cake
15.00
6 inch layer cake
25.00
ruby red velvet cake
our vintage red velvet cake with a southern cream cheese frosting
4 inch cutie cake
15.00
6 inch layer cake
25.00
happy hummingbird cake *not available in 4 in**
homemade hummingbird cake made with bananas, pineapple, and a few cozy spices covered in whipped cream cheese buttercream
30.00
seasonal ~ carrot cake
homemade carrot cake with whipped cream cheese buttercream
30.00
prairie bake house cupcakes
cupcakes can seem so "cliche" but they are so darn tasty!
lush lemon cupcakes
lemon lush cupcakes with lemon buttercream
4 count
12.00
1 dozen
36.00
intense chocolate cupcakes
rich and moist chocolate cake with choice of frosting: vanilla bean, fudgy buttercream, whipped peanut butter, or ganache
4 count
12.00
1 dozen
36.00
vintage vanilla bean cupcakes
vintage vanilla bean cupcakes with our classic vanilla bean buttercream
4 count
12.00
1 dozen
36.00
prairie bake house pies
simple home baked pies with a homemade crust.
prairie apple pie
9 inch apple filled pie with hints of cinnamon and nutmeg with a homemade pie crust
25.00
prairie apple crumble pie
9 inch apple filled pie with hints of cinnamon and nutmeg with a crisp buttery crumble topping
25.00
prairie cherry pie
cherry filled pie with a homemade pie crust
25.00
prairie cherry crumble pie
cherry filled pie with a crisp buttery crumble topping
25.00
lemon meringue pie
tart lemon curd brings the zing in this pie topped with fluffy meringue toasted just right
25.00
prairie peanut butter pie
this pie starts with a rich chocolate cookie crust and is then filled with a creamy peanut butter filling topped with swirls of whipped cream and some dashes of chocolate sauce
25.00
summer strawberry pie
summer sweet strawberries piled on a homemade butter crust brings back those dreams of a sunshiny picnic day with family.
25.00
sunday supper berry pie
after a slow sunday supper there is nothing like a pie filled with raspberries, blackberries, and cherries topped off with a scoop of vanilla ice cream
25.00
prairie pumpkin pie
spiced pumpkin pie with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. this pie just warms the heart right up!
25.00
prairie bake house cinnamon rolls
homemade cinnamon rolls w/ vanilla frosting
or vanilla maple frosting
prairie cinnamon rolls
homemade cinnamon rolls with vanilla frosting or vanilla maple frosting
Single serve
4.00
4 count
12.00
1 dozen
36.00
cinnamon star bread
star shaped cinnamon swirled bread w/ a cinnamon vanilla glaze
20.00
prairie bake house quick breads
homemade quick breads
lemon loaf
lemon bread with a lemon icing
8.00
lemon blueberry loaf
lemon blueberry bread with a lemon blueberry icing
8.00
banana bread
homestyle banana bread w/ walnuts
8.00
amish cinnamon loaf
amish quick bread swirled with a sweet cinnamon filling
8.00
lemon raspberry loaf
lemon loaf with raspberry swirl and lemon glaze
8.00
prairie bake house scones
fresh baked fluffy and buttery scones
bursting blueberry scones
blueberry scones with a lemon glaze
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
Single serve
3.00
lemon scones
lemon scones with a light lemon glaze
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
Single serve
3.00
raspberry almond scones
raspberry scones with almonds with a vanilla glaze
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
Single serve
3.00
vanilla almond scones
vanilla and almond scones with a vanilla glaze
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
single cookie
3.00
prairie bake house cookies
homemade cookies from my childhood
specialty decorated cookies
vanilla almond cutout sugar cookies with royal icing decoration. Regular size or mini cookies available.
Min order: 1 doz Regular size cookies
36.00
Min. order 2 doz mini cutout cookies
36.00
amish chocolate chip cookies
3oz brown butter chocolate chip cookie with extra chocolate chips **pecans upon request**
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
peanut butter passion cookie
3oz perfectly peanutty cookie with Reese's peanut butter chips and Reese's pieces. Grab a glass of milk and enjoy!
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
iced vanilla sugar cookies
3oz vanilla almond sugar cookie with creamy vanilla buttercream. Options available: birthday and holiday themed
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
chocolate peanut butter bliss
3oz rich chocolate cookie with reese's peanut butter chips
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
aunt marilyn's snickerdoodles
aunt marilyn’s snickerdoodles are more than just the classic cinnamon and sugar cookies—they’re a comforting reminder of memories with family, holiday gatherings, and the joy of homemade baking
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
prairie peanut butter cookies
3oz simple peanut butter cookie that reminds you of when you were a kid grabbing a cookie with a glass of milk after school
3oz red velvet cookie with swirls of cream cheese and white chocolate chips.
6 cookies
18.00
1 dozen
30.00
extra offerings
misc offerings from the prairie bake house
luscious lemon bars
tart and tangy lemon bars with a butter shortcrust will turn your day into pure sunshine
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
prairie brownie squares
squares of the best fudgy chocolatey brownies on the prairie.
4 count
10.00
8 count
20.00
prairie hand pies
flavors: homestead apple, wild cherry, summer peach, and triple berry
perfect hand held fruit pies for that perfect snack that takes you back to the good old days. homemade crust with fresh made filling baked to perfection and covered in a sweet vanilla glaze
4 count
12.00
8 count
24.00
Old fashioned cinnamon coffee cake
8x8 cinnamon coffee cake with layers of buttery cinnamon sugar swirls topped with a vanilla glaze *can add blueberries for $2
15.00
cindy's hot fudge sauce
12oz jar of homemade hot fudge sauce
8.00
grandma bea's egg noodles - 16oz
grandma's old egg noodle recipe that i have been making since i was just a little kid helping her in the kitchen. my mom and i made these together for every thanksgiving at my grandma's house.
